Image
ROCHESTER, MN (November 18, 2026).
Mayo Clinic is disputing the findings of a national hospital accountability study that calculated a $366 million difference between the tax benefits received by its Rochester hospital and the amount the institution spent on selected forms of charity care and community investment in fiscal year 2023.
The analysis, released Tuesday by the nonprofit Lown Institute, placed Mayo Clinic Hospital at the top of a national list of nonprofit hospitals whose estimated tax exemptions exceeded their spending on the categories of community benefit measured by the organization.
The findings have renewed debate over how nonprofit hospitals should demonstrate that their tax-exempt status produces meaningful benefits for the communities they serve.
Mayo Clinic challenged the report's methodology, arguing that the analysis excluded substantial contributions associated with research, medical education and the cost of caring for patients covered by Medicaid.
The dispute centers on what should count as community benefit and how the value of those activities should be compared with the public revenue governments forgo through hospital tax exemptions.
The Lown Institute examined financial information from more than 3,000 nonprofit hospitals across the United States, using fiscal year 2023 data drawn from federal tax filings, hospital cost reports and local property records.
Its analysis compared the estimated value of tax exemptions with spending in five categories: financial assistance, community health improvement services, subsidized health services, cash and in-kind contributions, and community-building activities.
The organization describes the difference as a hospital's fair share spending.
Under that methodology, Mayo Clinic Hospital in Rochester had a deficit of approximately $366 million, the largest identified in the national study.
The next-largest reported gaps included $294 million at Tisch Hospital in New York, $255 million at Stanford Hospital in California and $248 million at NewYork-Presbyterian Hospital.
The institute found that 52 percent of nonprofit hospitals received more in estimated tax benefits than they spent in the selected community investment categories.
Together, hospitals with such deficits accounted for approximately $15.5 billion in what the institute classified as insufficient community spending.
The findings do not mean that Mayo Clinic unlawfully received $366 million or that the organization owes that amount to the government.
The figure is a calculation produced by the institute's methodology, not a tax assessment, legal judgment or regulatory finding.
That distinction is essential to understanding the dispute.
Nonprofit hospitals generally receive exemptions from certain federal, state and local taxes because they operate for charitable purposes.
In exchange, they must satisfy applicable legal requirements, including obligations involving community benefit, financial assistance policies and other standards.
Federal rules recognize several categories of community benefit, but the Lown Institute uses a narrower set of measures to assess how directly hospitals support patients and communities.
Mayo argues that this narrower calculation omits important parts of its institutional mission.
In a statement reported by Minnesota news organizations, Mayo Clinic described the methodology as deeply flawed and said it did not adequately represent the organization's contributions.
The institution specifically identified Medicaid shortfalls, medical research and health professions education as categories recognized in federal community-benefit reporting but excluded from the institute's calculation.
Those exclusions matter particularly for an academic medical center whose operations include specialized patient care, research and professional training.
Mayo Clinic maintains that those activities produce benefits extending beyond the patients treated at its Rochester facilities.
The Lown Institute does not deny that hospitals perform research or train physicians.
Instead, it argues that such activities should not automatically be treated as equivalent to direct community investment when evaluating the public value of tax exemptions.
The organization has questioned whether research funded through other sources should be counted again as a charitable contribution and whether all medical education expenditures necessarily address the healthcare needs of surrounding communities.
Those competing positions reflect a broader disagreement about the responsibilities of tax-exempt hospitals.
One approach places substantial weight on the full range of medical services, research and training performed by an institution.
Another emphasizes direct assistance to patients who cannot afford care and investments that address identified community health needs.
The difference can produce dramatically different assessments of the same hospital.
The issue is especially consequential in Minnesota, where healthcare affordability and hospital billing practices have become subjects of increasing public scrutiny.
Mayo Clinic has previously faced questions about its financial assistance and debt collection policies.
In May 2025, Minnesota Attorney General Keith Ellison's office reached a settlement with Mayo requiring changes to its charity care and debt collection practices.
The Attorney General's Office said its investigation identified barriers that prevented some eligible patients from obtaining financial assistance and raised concerns about aggressive collection practices.
That settlement is separate from the Lown Institute's new study and should not be treated as a legal finding concerning the $366 million calculation.
It nevertheless provides relevant context for the continuing discussion about whether nonprofit hospitals are making financial assistance sufficiently accessible.
The debate also concerns transparency.
Patients, taxpayers and policymakers need information that allows them to understand how hospitals calculate community benefit, which populations receive assistance and how institutional spending addresses identified healthcare needs.
A hospital may report substantial community-benefit expenditures while patients continue experiencing difficulty understanding eligibility requirements or obtaining assistance.
Conversely, an analysis that excludes significant categories of institutional activity may present an incomplete picture of the benefits a hospital provides.
Both concerns deserve examination.
The Lown Institute's study provides one standardized method for comparing hospitals, but it is not the only framework under which nonprofit community benefits can be evaluated.
Mayo Clinic's response identifies important categories omitted from that framework, but the existence of those categories does not independently resolve whether the institution's direct investments in patient assistance and community health are sufficient.
A comprehensive evaluation would require examining the institution's complete financial disclosures, the value of its tax exemptions, the distribution of financial assistance and the measurable benefits of its research, education and community programs.
The national findings have prompted calls for stronger reporting standards and clearer expectations for nonprofit hospitals.
The Lown Institute recommends tighter charity care requirements, improved transparency and minimum community investment standards.
For Minnesota residents, the question reaches beyond a disagreement between one hospital and one research organization.
Tax exemptions represent a public policy decision to support institutions that serve charitable purposes. Evaluating those institutions requires credible financial information and an understanding of how their resources benefit patients and communities.
Mayo Clinic remains one of Minnesota's most prominent healthcare institutions, with a national and international reputation for medical care, research and education.
The new report does not erase those contributions. It raises a specific question about the relationship between tax benefits and direct community spending, using a methodology the institution disputes.
Resolving that disagreement requires more than accepting either side's preferred calculation without scrutiny.
It requires a transparent accounting of what nonprofit hospitals receive, what they provide and how their charitable obligations translate into meaningful healthcare access for the people they serve.

Local stories matter. Subscribe free to MinneapoliMedia and receive independent news, community reporting and important updates from Minneapolis, the North Metro and communities across Minnesota.
SUBSCRIBE FREE: https://minneapolimedia.town.news/subscribe
MinneapoliMedia | Community. Culture. Civic Life