MINNEAPOLIMEDIA PRESENTS | COMMUNITY INTERVIEW SERIES: From Kashmir to Minnesota, Fatima Basharat's Journey of Faith, Compassion and the Courage to Change

An earthquake changed her family. Mentors challenged her understanding of religion. A journey from Pakistan to the United States opened new questions about justice, belonging and human connection. Today, Fatima Basharat brings those experiences into hospital rooms and Minnesota college campuses, where listening has become both her profession and a continuing lesson in how to live.

NORTHFIELD, MN (October 16, 2026).

Fatima Basharat was eight years old when an earthquake in Kashmir changed her family. On October 8, 2005, a devastating earthquake struck northern Pakistan and the Kashmir region, killing tens of thousands of people and destroying entire communities. Among those who died were Basharat's paternal uncle and his wife. Their children survived, but both parents were gone.

At the time, Basharat was living in Saudi Arabia with her parents and siblings. Her father worked there to support the family. Following the earthquake, her mother returned to Pakistan with her children and welcomed the orphaned cousins into their household. Basharat's father remained in Saudi Arabia, continuing to earn a living for the enlarged family.

The cousins became siblings, and Basharat grew up in a household that had expanded almost overnight. As a child, she accepted the arrangement as part of family life. Only as an adult did she begin to appreciate the responsibility her mother had undertaken.

"I think it's such a beautiful thing to do," Basharat said during an October 9 interview with MinneapoliMedia. "I don't think a lot of people can do it."

Her admiration for her mother has grown with time. She understands more clearly the emotional and practical demands of raising children who had experienced profound loss while continuing to care for her own family.

"A lot of who I am right now, a lot of the characteristics that I hold, are also the characteristics of my mom," she reflected.

Today, Basharat serves as associate chaplain for Muslim and interfaith life at Carleton College and St. Olaf College in Northfield, Minnesota. She is also completing clinical pastoral education at Fairview Hospital, where she works with patients and families confronting illness, grief, fear and uncertainty.

Her professional life places her in situations where people may be frightened, overwhelmed or struggling to make sense of circumstances beyond their control. She listens to patients whose religious beliefs differ from hers, supports college students questioning their identities and helps people navigate disagreements that may have damaged important relationships.

The path to that work was far from predictable. Basharat once expected to become a doctor. She later pursued Islamic Studies, spent a formative year in Turkey, returned to Pakistan after political upheaval disrupted her education and eventually moved to the United States to study peacebuilding. Along the way, she reconsidered assumptions about religion, justice and the meaning of understanding another person.

The Girl Who Wanted to Become a Doctor

Basharat traces her roots to Pakistan-administered Kashmir, although part of her childhood was spent in Saudi Arabia. Her upbringing was shaped by family relationships, religious traditions and the responsibilities that followed the 2005 earthquake.

Religion was present in her household, but she does not describe her family as exceptionally religious. Prayer and other practices were part of everyday life, and her early understanding of Islam reflected the environment in which she grew up.

Her first professional ambition was medicine.

"Like every Pakistani girl, I wanted to become a doctor," she recalled, referring to the social expectations that made certain careers particularly desirable.

That ambition changed during her teenage years at PakTurk, a Turkish-affiliated school in Pakistan, where she met a mentor named Sana.

Basharat remembered Sana's kindness, guidance and interest in her development. Sana was studying Islamic Studies, and the younger Basharat admired her enough to consider following the same academic path.

The decision grew from a personal relationship. Basharat saw in Sana someone she respected and wanted to emulate. Islamic Studies gradually replaced medicine as the future she imagined for herself.

Another mentor, whom Basharat did not identify by name, would later influence her understanding of religion in a different way. This person challenged her assumptions with compassion and helped her develop a deeper appreciation for pluralism.

Basharat has emphasized the distinction between their contributions. Sana inspired her interest in Islamic Studies. The second mentor helped her reconsider how she understood religious difference.

Both relationships became important as she began moving beyond the beliefs she had inherited toward a more deliberate understanding of her faith.

A Year in Turkey and an Education Interrupted

At 18, Basharat moved to Turkey with plans to complete her undergraduate education there. She settled in Kayseri and spent a year studying Turkish at Melikşah University, expecting the language program to prepare her for further studies.

Her plans were disrupted by the attempted coup in Turkey in July 2016 and the political crackdown that followed. Melikşah University was closed, and its campus was subsequently transferred to Erciyes University.

Basharat returned to Pakistan without completing the undergraduate education she had intended to pursue in Turkey.

She nevertheless remembers the year as one of the most important periods of her personal development. The teachers, mentors and friendships she encountered introduced her to ideas about religion, community and service that continued to influence her long after she left.

In subsequent correspondence with MinneapoliMedia, Basharat described the experience as transformational and expressed enduring gratitude to the people who supported her.

Those relationships also introduced her more closely to the Hizmet movement, a Turkish-origin movement whose name translates as service. Its emphasis on education, community engagement and interfaith relationships became important to her developing understanding of pluralism.

The political events that interrupted her education would later give those relationships another dimension. Basharat had come to know teachers and community members whose lives were affected by the crackdown against people associated with Hizmet.

Their experiences troubled her, particularly because she regarded many of them as people who had encouraged peace, education and understanding across religious differences.

Back in Pakistan, Basharat enrolled at International Islamic University, Islamabad, where she completed a bachelor's degree in Islamic Studies, majoring in Comparative Religions.

The program allowed her to study Islam alongside other religious traditions. It also brought her into contact with interpretations of faith that she would eventually begin to question.

Questioning Religious Certainty

Basharat speaks candidly about her early years studying Islamic Studies. Although she remains grateful for her education, she believes some of the instruction encouraged a more rigid understanding of religion than the one she holds today.

As a young student, she developed strong opinions about acceptable religious practices and interpretations. She sometimes distanced herself from people who did not share those views.

"I started to push people who did not believe in the same ideology that I had, or the same ideas I had," she acknowledged.

She now recognizes how easily religious certainty can become a barrier to understanding others. At the time, however, she was a young woman trying to develop a serious commitment to her faith.

Her relationships with people associated with Hizmet contributed to a change in her thinking. Through conversations with mentors and friends, she encountered interpretations of religious life that placed greater emphasis on appreciating differences.

The movement also became connected to her concern about injustice. Basharat described teachers and community members whom she believed had been unfairly targeted because of their perceived association with Hizmet.

She spoke about accusations of terrorism, the closure of educational institutions and people being taken from Pakistan to Turkey. These developments were particularly troubling because some of those affected were people she knew personally.

Basharat has been careful to explain that Hizmet did not introduce her to the importance of justice.

"Justice is something very core to who I am," she said during the interview.

In a subsequent clarification, she reiterated that justice had always been one of her central values. Her experiences involving Hizmet gave her opportunities to act on that commitment, but they did not create it.

The movement's more significant influence concerned pluralism.

Basharat began reconsidering the assumption that meaningful relationships required people to share the same religious interpretations. She found that people could remain committed to their beliefs while treating different perspectives with respect.

"I think there's beauty in embracing the differences too," she said.

She compared human differences to snowflakes. Although snowflakes may appear similar from a distance, each has its own characteristics. Basharat believes religious traditions should be approached with similar appreciation for their distinctiveness.

Her studies in Comparative Religions reinforced that understanding. She examined Hinduism, Buddhism, Christianity, Judaism and other traditions, developing a deeper appreciation for beliefs she had previously encountered mainly through friends and acquaintances.

Basharat had grown up in a Sunni Muslim household, but she became increasingly reluctant to define herself through sectarian categories.

"I just want to say I'm Muslim and a human being and a soul seeker," she said.

Her changing understanding did not mean that she had abandoned Islam or become indifferent to religious practice. She remained committed to her faith while becoming more comfortable acknowledging that other people understood religion differently.

During her university years in Islamabad, she also participated in mentoring young women who had arrived from other parts of Pakistan. The work, undertaken through Hizmet, gave her opportunities to support people adjusting to unfamiliar circumstances and pursuing their education.

Those experiences would later inform her interest in chaplaincy, although she had not yet decided to make spiritual care her profession.

Loving Pakistan While Confronting Its Injustices

Basharat's growing interest in religious difference developed alongside a concern for people facing discrimination and exclusion in Pakistan.

During the interview, she discussed the treatment of transgender and intersex people, child labor, the experiences of religious minorities, and the circumstances of marginalized communities, including people in Balochistan and Afghan refugees.

She spoke about these issues as someone who loves Pakistan and remains connected to its people. She does not believe that affection for a country requires silence about injustice.

That distinction became particularly important after she moved to the United States.

Basharat recalled encountering assumptions that leaving Pakistan meant escaping a country with little to offer, or that America had somehow rescued her from her homeland.

She rejects that interpretation.

Pakistan remains a place of family, culture, friendship and belonging. She recognizes its beauty and the generosity of its people while maintaining that serious problems deserve attention.

Her understanding of identity also changed after migration.

In Pakistan, where Muslims constitute the overwhelming majority, her religious identity was part of the social environment around her. In the United States, she became a member of a religious minority.

She had followed American political developments before arriving, including the restrictions imposed on travelers from several predominantly Muslim countries during the first Trump administration. Those events shaped some of her expectations about living in the United States.

Yet she also wanted to experience a different society and deepen her understanding of peacebuilding.

After completing her undergraduate studies, Basharat explored opportunities for graduate education abroad. She considered programs in several countries, including Australia and New Zealand.

A former teacher eventually directed her attention to Hartford International University in Connecticut, where she found a program that connected religious studies with peacebuilding.

She applied and was accepted.

Leaving Pakistan meant moving far from family and entering an unfamiliar environment without relatives nearby. Basharat now regards that decision as evidence of an independence she did not fully recognize in herself at the time.

Finding Belonging at Hartford

Basharat arrived in the United States with questions about how she would be received as a Muslim woman.

She was familiar with American political debates concerning Islam, immigration and national security. She wondered how those discussions might affect her daily life.

Her experience at Hartford International University proved more welcoming than she had anticipated.

She found professors who encouraged difficult questions, classmates from different religious and cultural backgrounds, and friendships that gradually became central to her life in the United States.

The university offered an environment where she felt comfortable expressing her beliefs and learning from others.

She later recognized that Hartford provided a particularly supportive setting and that Muslims elsewhere in the country could have very different experiences.

Nevertheless, the relationships she formed there helped her build a sense of belonging while living far from her family.

Her graduate studies also changed how she understood conflict.

Basharat became interested in the distinction between conflict resolution and conflict transformation. She questioned the expectation that disagreements must always end with an identifiable settlement or a complete removal of differences.

"Conflict will always exist," she said.

In her understanding, conflict is part of human relationships. People bring different histories, values, expectations and experiences into their interactions. Those differences cannot always be eliminated.

She increasingly favored an approach that examines how people can change their relationships with one another even when disagreement remains.

That requires attention to the experiences underlying a conflict. Basharat believes people must be willing to hear how others understand events, what they fear and why certain issues carry particular emotional weight.

Her interest in peacebuilding also extended beyond academic study.

During her graduate education, she participated virtually in an initiative organized by an Indonesian colleague who wanted to strengthen understanding between Muslim and Christian communities.

The colleague's experiences of religious violence had influenced his commitment to creating opportunities for dialogue. Basharat joined conversations intended to help participants learn about one another's religious experiences.

The initiative reinforced her belief that personal relationships can help people approach religious differences with greater understanding.

Her later experiences, however, also taught her that dialogue has limitations. People cannot always be brought together simply because a conversation appears desirable.

Sometimes the timing is wrong.

When Dialogue Becomes Difficult

Basharat's reflections on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict reveal how difficult it can be to practice the principles of pluralism during periods of intense suffering.

Following October 7, 2023, she experienced strain in relationships with people whose interpretations of the conflict differed sharply from her own.

The disagreements involved grief, fear, historical memory and deeply held moral convictions. They were not conversations in which participants could easily separate their opinions from their personal identities.

Basharat acknowledged that her own reactions sometimes challenged the values she had spent years developing.

"I realized that I stopped seeing them as humans," she said, describing moments when she had begun identifying people primarily with positions she strongly opposed.

The realization troubled her.

She had learned to resist reducing people to religious or ideological categories, yet she recognized that the emotional intensity of the conflict had affected her ability to extend that understanding consistently.

Her experience also led her to question the assumption that dialogue is always appropriate.

"There are times when dialogues are important and necessary," she said. "And then there are times when dialogues don't work, and that is okay, too."

People experiencing profound grief or fear may need time among those who understand their circumstances before attempting difficult conversations with people whose positions they find painful.

Basharat does not regard that need for distance as a permanent rejection of reconciliation. She believes the conditions surrounding a conversation matter.

Relationships established before a crisis may be better equipped to withstand disagreement than relationships people attempt to create for the first time during intense conflict.

She referred to Barefoot Dialogue, a sustained-dialogue initiative at Oberlin College in Ohio founded by David Dorsey, as an example of the importance of building relationships over time.

The initiative has included conversations concerning Israel and Palestine and questions of Jewish identity. Basharat discussed how structured dialogue can help participants develop relationships before disagreements become overwhelming.

She also emphasized the importance of facilitation.

Participants need opportunities to speak honestly without feeling pressured to accept another person's position. Acknowledging someone's experience does not require agreement with that person's interpretation of events.

Basharat recognizes that relationships can also develop during crises, particularly when people share experiences of suffering. The greater difficulty, she suggested, often involves building relationships across profoundly different understandings of the same events.

Her reflections were shaped by both academic study and personal experience. She had witnessed how political and religious disagreements could strain friendships, and she had confronted limitations in her own ability to respond compassionately.

Those experiences became relevant to her work in chaplaincy, where listening to another person does not always mean resolving that person's distress.

Entering Hospital Rooms Without an Agenda

"I think hospitals are such a tender place," Basharat said.

Her work in clinical pastoral education brings her into contact with patients and families experiencing some of the most difficult moments of their lives.

Patients may be confronting serious diagnoses, preparing for surgery, grieving recent losses or struggling with loneliness. Some are reluctant to share their fears with family members because they do not want to become an additional burden.

Others may have no one immediately available to listen.

Basharat approaches those encounters without assuming that she knows what a patient needs.

Sometimes a patient wants to discuss faith. Another may want to talk about family, fear, regret or uncertainty. Some prefer silence. Others do not want a chaplain to visit.

She has learned to respect those differences.

Early in her training, Basharat sometimes found it difficult when patients declined spiritual care. She wondered whether their refusal reflected something she had done wrong.

With experience, she came to understand that the encounter was not about her feelings.

Patients have the right to decide whether they want spiritual care. That choice is particularly important in a hospital, where people may have limited control over other aspects of their circumstances.

Basharat also supports patients whose religious beliefs differ from her own, including people who do not identify with any religious tradition.

She does not approach those conversations as opportunities to persuade patients to adopt her beliefs.

"My faith, my understanding, how I make meaning, is just at the back burner," she explained.

She compared herself to a blank canvas, allowing the patient's experiences and concerns to shape the encounter.

The approach requires her to listen without deciding in advance what the conversation should accomplish.

A patient may want reassurance, but another may need space to express anger or uncertainty. Some people are not seeking an answer. They want someone willing to hear what they are experiencing.

Basharat understands that a chaplain cannot reverse a diagnosis, eliminate grief or resolve every family conflict.

Spiritual care may instead involve helping someone articulate fears that have remained unspoken or recognize that their feelings can be acknowledged without judgment.

She regards those encounters as meaningful even when they do not produce a visible change in circumstances.

For Basharat, being present with another person is a responsibility that requires attention, patience and respect for the limits of what she can offer.

Supporting Students at Carleton and St. Olaf

Basharat's work at Carleton College and St. Olaf College involves a different set of circumstances, although many of the questions students bring to her concern identity, uncertainty and belonging.

College can be the first time young people live among classmates whose religious practices, cultural backgrounds or political beliefs differ substantially from those of their families.

Some students welcome the experience. Others find themselves questioning assumptions they had never previously examined.

Basharat understands that uncertainty from her own education.

She remembers how difficult it was to reconsider religious ideas she had once regarded as settled. She also knows that encountering unfamiliar perspectives does not necessarily require a person to abandon deeply held convictions.

"I love working with students," she said. "I think they challenge you so much sometimes."

Students approach her with questions about religion, friendships, family expectations, career decisions and their futures.

Some are trying to understand their identities. Others are struggling with relationships or the pressure to meet academic expectations.

Basharat is particularly concerned about the emphasis placed on constant productivity.

She sees students who feel compelled to fill their schedules with activities, academic commitments and professional preparation. The pressure can make rest appear unproductive or undeserved.

She questions that assumption.

Basharat described wanting to be "a little bit counterculture" by encouraging students to slow down and recognize the importance of rest.

She believes students should have opportunities to develop interests and relationships that are not measured entirely by academic or professional achievement.

Her work also includes supporting students affected by immigration enforcement and changes in federal policy.

During the interview, she discussed anxiety among international students, Somali students and others whose families or communities have been affected by immigration-related developments.

For those students, questions about belonging can involve concerns about personal safety, family separation or the ability to remain in the United States.

Basharat regards helping students process those fears as an important part of her responsibilities.

She also recognizes that some students may be more comfortable discussing personal concerns with a chaplain than in classrooms or other institutional settings.

Their willingness to share those experiences requires trust.

Basharat considers that trust a privilege, and she believes the students she supports continually contribute to her own education.

Their questions challenge her assumptions and introduce her to experiences she might otherwise never encounter.

The Chaplain Who Is Learning to Rest

For someone who encourages students to resist constant productivity, Basharat acknowledges that she struggles to follow her own advice.

Her responsibilities across two college campuses, combined with clinical pastoral education at Fairview, have created a demanding schedule.

"Every day is such a packed day," she admitted.

She has begun questioning whether she gives herself enough time for rest and personal interests.

The concern is particularly significant because much of her professional life involves supporting people through emotionally demanding experiences.

She understands the importance of care and restoration, but finding time for those things in her own life has become difficult.

Basharat enjoys hiking and spending time outdoors. During the interview, she spoke about plans to visit Willow River State Park in Wisconsin.

She also finds comfort in poetry, friendships and community relationships.

Painting, however, occupies a particularly important place in her memories.

She painted more frequently while living in Pakistan. Since moving to the United States, she has struggled to maintain that interest.

She suspects that the demands of work and the expectation of constant productivity have contributed to the change.

"I just love playing with colors," she said.

Basharat does not describe herself as an accomplished artist. She enjoys painting because it allows her to experiment and create without the pressure of producing something professionally useful.

When asked whether she would encourage her younger self to follow the same path, she answered yes.

She remains grateful for her education, friendships and opportunities to work in chaplaincy. She regards the profession as meaningful and considers accompanying people through difficult experiences a privilege.

But she would also offer her younger self another piece of advice.

"Do not let go of your dream of becoming an artist."

Her answer reflects an ambition that has remained important despite the changes in her life.

She does not regret becoming a chaplain. She wants to recover a part of herself that received more attention before work and professional responsibilities became so demanding.

The Courage to Leave and the Willingness to Keep Learning

Looking back on her journey from Pakistan to Minnesota, Basharat is struck by the independence required to leave home and begin a life in another country.

She arrived in the United States without relatives nearby and gradually developed friendships that became an important source of belonging.

The distance from her family has not always been easy.

She nevertheless regards the experience as evidence of a courage she did not fully recognize when she first decided to move.

Her understanding of relationships has also changed.

Professors, mentors, friends and colleagues have encouraged her to reconsider assumptions about religion, conflict, love and authenticity. Some challenged her beliefs directly. Others helped her recognize qualities and convictions she already possessed.

She remains grateful for those relationships and for the opportunities they have given her to develop personally and professionally.

When asked what she hopes to accomplish in the coming years, Basharat did not identify a particular professional title or institutional position.

She spoke instead about continuing to learn.

"I hope that I never become a person who stops being curious," she said.

Her life has already taken directions she could not have anticipated as a child.

She once wanted to become a doctor. A mentor inspired her to study religion. Political upheaval interrupted her education in Turkey. Her studies in Pakistan challenged her understanding of religious difference. Graduate education in the United States introduced her to peacebuilding and eventually chaplaincy.

She now works with patients and students whose experiences often differ substantially from her own.

Basharat does not claim to have resolved every question those encounters raise. She continues to reconsider her assumptions and recognizes that even deeply held commitments to compassion and pluralism can be tested by personal experiences.

Her mother's decision after the 2005 earthquake remains an important part of how she understands care.

As a child, Basharat grew up alongside cousins who had lost their parents and become members of her immediate household. Only later did she fully appreciate what her mother had undertaken.

That family history remains meaningful as Basharat develops her own understanding of responsibility toward others.

Her work now involves listening to patients who are frightened or grieving, supporting students facing uncertainty and respecting people whose beliefs may differ from hers.

Outside work, she is trying to give more attention to her own needs, including rest, time outdoors and painting.

She hopes to remain open to unfamiliar perspectives and willing to reconsider what she believes.

And she still wants to spend more time with her paints.

EDITOR’S NOTE Fatima Basharat spoke with Tom Akaolisa for MinneapoliMedia's Community Interview Series on October 9, 2026. The interview explored her childhood in Kashmir and Saudi Arabia, education in Pakistan and Turkey, graduate studies in the United States, work in chaplaincy, and evolving understanding of faith, justice and human connection.

❤️ SUPPORT MINNEAPOLIMEDIA


STAY CONNECTED TO MINNEAPOLIMEDIA

Local stories matter. Subscribe free to MinneapoliMedia and receive independent news, community reporting and important updates from Minneapolis, the North Metro and communities across Minnesota.

SUBSCRIBE FREE: https://minneapolimedia.town.news/subscribe

MinneapoliMedia | Community. Culture. Civic Life

I'm interested
I disagree with this
This is unverified
Spam
Offensive