MINNEAPOLIMEDIA NEWS | One Disputed Ballot Reverses Spring Lake Park Mayoral Election as Court Challenge Looms
After a 1,401–1,401 tie, a drawing of lots and a recount, challenger Halyn Roth was declared the winner over incumbent Mayor Robert Nelson. The canvassing board rejected the city administrator's recommendation on a contested ballot, leaving the possibility of judicial review.
SPRING LAKE PARK, MN (November 19, 2026).
An extraordinary mayoral election in Spring Lake Park has taken another unexpected turn after a disputed ballot changed the apparent outcome of a race that originally ended in a tie, raising questions about voter intent, recount procedures and the authority of local election officials.
Challenger Halyn Roth has been declared the winner over incumbent Mayor Robert Nelson following a recount and a decision by the city's canvassing board to exclude one contested vote.
The decision reversed the outcome of an earlier drawing of lots that had awarded the election to Nelson under Minnesota's procedures for resolving tied races.
Nelson now has seven days to challenge the result in Anoka County District Court, according to reporting by Minnesota Public Radio News.
The dispute illustrates how a single ballot can determine the outcome of a local election and how disagreements over voter intent can move from election administration into the judicial system.
An Election That Ended in an Exact Tie
The November mayoral election initially produced an extraordinary result.
Nelson and Roth each received exactly 1,401 votes, leaving the two candidates tied after 2,802 votes had been counted.
Minnesota law provides a process for resolving certain tied elections through the drawing of lots.
On November 9, Spring Lake Park officials placed the candidates' names inside identical containers and conducted a random drawing at City Hall.
Nelson's name was selected.
The result appeared to settle the contest, but Roth requested a recount shortly afterward.
That request initiated another examination of the ballots and ultimately changed the election's outcome.
Recount Brings One Ballot Into Dispute
The recount took place Tuesday, November 17, at the Anoka County Courthouse.
Election workers examined ballots by hand to determine whether votes had been properly recorded and whether voter intent could be established in cases involving unusual or ambiguous markings.
Both candidates identified ballots for additional review.
According to MPR News, the candidates ultimately agreed with election workers' determinations on the challenged ballots except for one.
The remaining disputed ballot contained a pen marking in the oval beside Nelson's name and a small dot in the oval beside Roth's name.
The issue was whether the markings sufficiently established the voter's intended choice.
Election officials routinely confront such questions when ballots contain corrections, incomplete markings or other irregularities.
The standard is not simply whether a ballot contains an unusual mark, but whether the voter's intent can be determined under applicable election rules.
City Administrator Recommends Counting Vote for Nelson
Spring Lake Park City Administrator Daniel Buchholtz recommended that the contested ballot be counted for Nelson.
Buchholtz, who cited approximately 25 years of experience in Minnesota election administration, said he believed the voter's intent could be determined.
His recommendation would have rejected Roth's challenge to the ballot.
However, the ultimate decision rested with the canvassing board, which in Spring Lake Park consists of the City Council.
The board voted 3–1 to sustain Roth's challenge.
Nelson abstained from the vote, while Council Member Barbara Goodboe-Bisschoff voted against sustaining the challenge.
The decision excluded the contested vote from Nelson's total, resulting in Roth being declared the winner by one vote.
The reversal transformed an election initially decided by chance into one determined by a disagreement over the interpretation of a single ballot.
Council Members Defend Their Decision
Council Member Ken Wendling, who supported sustaining Roth's challenge, told MPR News that members reviewed both sides of the ballot before reaching their decision.
Wendling said the mark in Nelson's oval appeared less distinct than markings made in other races on the ballot.
That observation was part of the reasoning behind the decision to exclude the vote.
The disagreement between the city administrator and the canvassing board does not, by itself, establish that either side acted improperly.
Instead, it reflects differing judgments about whether the ballot satisfied the legal standard for identifying voter intent.
The canvassing board had the authority to resolve the challenge, subject to any available judicial review.
Incumbent May Seek Court Intervention
Nelson has a seven-day window to file an election contest in Anoka County District Court.
If he does so, a judge could review the disputed ballot and the canvassing board's decision.
Depending on the court's findings, judicial review could potentially alter the outcome again.
However, no court challenge had been confirmed in the MPR reporting available for this article.
Wendling told MPR News that Nelson appeared prepared to pursue legal action, recalling that the mayor indicated he expected to see council members in court.
Nelson had not responded to MPR News' requests for comment at the time of its report.
Roth, meanwhile, issued a statement indicating that he was preparing for the transition to the mayor's office while recognizing Nelson's right to pursue legal remedies.
Roth said he would refrain from additional public comment while the electoral and legal processes remained unresolved.
Why One Ballot Matters Beyond Spring Lake Park
Although Spring Lake Park is a relatively small city in the northern Twin Cities metropolitan area, its mayoral election raises questions relevant to voters throughout Minnesota.
Election results depend not only on counting ballots but also on the consistent application of rules governing voter intent, recounts and contested votes.
When an election is decided by a narrow margin, decisions that might otherwise attract little public attention can determine who holds public office.
The Spring Lake Park dispute also illustrates the relationship between election administrators and canvassing boards.
Administrators may provide recommendations based on election law and professional experience, while canvassing boards are responsible for making decisions within their legal authority.
Courts can then review certain disputes when a candidate files a timely election contest.
Those safeguards are intended to provide an orderly process for resolving disagreements rather than allowing disputed results to remain indefinitely unsettled.
A Test of Public Confidence
The mayoral contest has already moved through several stages: an exact tie, a drawing of lots, a requested recount, a challenged ballot and a canvassing board decision reversing the apparent winner.
A court proceeding could add another stage.
For residents, the central issue is whether the final outcome reflects the lawful counting of votes and the consistent application of election procedures.
The dispute is not evidence, by itself, of election fraud or deliberate manipulation.
It is a documented disagreement over the interpretation of one ballot in an exceptionally close contest.
As the deadline for a possible court challenge approaches, Spring Lake Park residents await clarity about who will lead their city.
The final resolution may turn on a single question: whether the disputed ballot clearly expressed a vote for Robert Nelson.
Until that question is resolved through the applicable legal process, the extraordinary 2026 Spring Lake Park mayoral election remains a significant example of how much one vote can matter.

STAY CONNECTED TO MINNEAPOLIMEDIA
Local stories matter. Subscribe free to MinneapoliMedia and receive independent news, community reporting and important updates from Minneapolis, the North Metro and communities across Minnesota.
SUBSCRIBE FREE: https://minneapolimedia.town.news/subscribe
MinneapoliMedia | Community. Culture. Civic Life