MINNEAPOLIMEDIA NEWS | Minnesota Orders Independent Audit of Xcel Energy After Years of Billing Errors and Customer Complaints

State utility regulators rejected the company's request to investigate itself, citing persistent problems involving inaccurate bills, disputed charges, payment arrangements and customer service.

ST. PAUL, MN (November 21, 2026).

Minnesota utility regulators have ordered an independent audit of Xcel Energy after years of billing errors and customer service complaints raised questions about the company's treatment of households, businesses and public institutions.

The Minnesota Public Utilities Commission unanimously approved the outside review Thursday, November 19, following an investigation into the utility's billing practices and its response to customer concerns.

The Minnesota Department of Commerce will oversee the audit, which Xcel must finance. A final report is expected by the end of 2027.

The decision follows a substantial increase in complaints involving incorrect bills, delayed payments and credits, difficulties establishing affordable payment arrangements and prolonged efforts to resolve disputes.

For Minnesota customers, the problems have sometimes involved more than the inconvenience of contacting a utility company. Billing disputes can affect household budgets, business finances and the ability of customers to understand what they owe.

Regulators Describe Persistent Problems

The commission began examining Xcel's billing practices last year after complaints increased over several years.

The record included submissions from individual customers, businesses, schools, churches and municipalities.

Some customers reported difficulty securing manageable payment plans after falling behind on their bills. Others described incorrect account information, unresolved charges or credits that had not been applied.

Businesses and public institutions also reported administrative difficulties.

Some organizations with solar installations said they had not received appropriate credits for electricity generated through their systems.

Municipal officials described spending considerable staff time attempting to correct billing problems.

St. Paul officials reported incidents involving incorrect bills, misapplied payments and delayed billing.

The range of complaints suggested that the problems were not confined to a single customer category or isolated administrative error.

Commissioner Audrey Partridge said the agency had observed unusually high complaint levels beginning in 2023, with problems continuing into 2026.

Regulators questioned why the utility had not resolved the issues despite years of warnings and opportunities to improve.

A Customer Service Call Draws Scrutiny

During Thursday's hearing, commissioners examined a recorded telephone conversation involving an Xcel customer service representative and a Public Utilities Commission mediator attempting to help a customer establish a payment plan.

The mediator explained that the customer had experienced a death in the family that affected her income.

She proposed an initial payment of $300 followed by monthly payments of the same amount.

The Xcel representative rejected the proposal.

When a supervisor became involved, the supervisor questioned whether the person calling was genuinely representing the commission.

The exchange became an example of the difficulties regulators said customers were encountering when seeking assistance.

Xcel's senior director of customer care, Matthew Chad, apologized for the company's handling of the call and acknowledged that the interaction did not meet the standard customers should expect.

The incident reinforced regulators' concerns about whether the utility's internal procedures adequately address customers experiencing financial hardship.

Commission Rejects Internal Review

Xcel asked regulators to allow the company to conduct its own examination of the problems.

The commission rejected that approach.

Commissioners concluded that the length and persistence of the complaints justified independent scrutiny.

The decision also reflects the special responsibilities of a regulated utility.

Xcel operates within a system in which utilities receive protected service territories and regulated opportunities to recover costs and earn returns. In exchange, they are expected to provide adequate service under public oversight.

Customers generally cannot choose another electric distribution company when they are dissatisfied with billing or customer service.

That makes the effectiveness of regulatory supervision particularly important.

Commissioners also questioned whether Xcel's senior leadership had devoted sufficient attention to the problems and whether executive compensation adequately reflected customer service performance.

Xcel Acknowledges Need for Improvement

Company representatives told regulators that Xcel had taken steps to improve billing accuracy, reduce backlogs and resolve problems involving solar credits.

The utility also reported additional training for customer service employees.

Xcel maintained that its efforts had produced progress, including reductions in some complaint categories.

Nevertheless, the company acknowledged that further improvements were necessary.

Following the commission's decision, Xcel said it would cooperate with the independent auditor and work to improve the accuracy of its bills and the responsiveness of its customer service operations.

The audit is expected to examine the utility's billing and customer service practices and provide an independent assessment of the problems regulators have identified.

What the Audit Means for Customers

The commission's order establishes a formal process for examining problems that customers have reported for years.

It does not immediately resolve individual billing disputes, eliminate outstanding charges or establish compensation for customers who believe they were billed incorrectly.

Those questions will depend on the circumstances of individual cases and any subsequent regulatory action.

The audit's findings could help regulators determine whether additional corrective measures are needed.

For customers, the most immediate concern remains the accuracy of bills, the timely application of payments and credits, and access to effective assistance when disputes arise.

The commission's decision places responsibility on Xcel to demonstrate that its systems and customer service practices can meet those expectations.

With the audit expected to continue into 2027, the company faces sustained regulatory scrutiny over services that are essential to Minnesota households and businesses.

❤️ SUPPORT MINNEAPOLIMEDIA


STAY CONNECTED TO MINNEAPOLIMEDIA

Local stories matter. Subscribe free to MinneapoliMedia and receive independent news, community reporting and important updates from Minneapolis, the North Metro and communities across Minnesota.

SUBSCRIBE FREE: https://minneapolimedia.town.news/subscribe

MinneapoliMedia | Community. Culture. Civic Life

I'm interested
I disagree with this
This is unverified
Spam
Offensive