MINNEAPOLIMEDIA NEWS | Three Minnesota Photojournalists Sue St. Paul Police Over Alleged Use of Force During Immigration Protest
Journalists working for MPR News, Sahan Journal, and independently allege that officers used pepper balls, chemical irritants, and tear gas against them while they documented a federal immigration operation. The lawsuit raises questions about press freedom and police crowd-control practices.
ST. PAUL, MN (November 20, 2026).
Three Minnesota photojournalists have filed a lawsuit against St. Paul police officials, alleging that officers used excessive force against them while they were documenting a federal immigration enforcement operation and the protests that followed in November 2025.
The lawsuit, reported Thursday, November 19, by the Minnesota Reformer, concerns an incident on November 25, 2025, in St. Paul's Payne-Phalen neighborhood.
The plaintiffs are Aaron Nesheim of Sahan Journal, Kerem Yücel of MPR News, and freelance photojournalist Timothy Evans.
They allege that St. Paul police officers fired pepper balls, deployed tear gas, and used pepper spray against journalists who were visibly engaged in newsgathering.
The allegations have not been established as judicial findings. The lawsuit initiates a legal process in which the defendants will have an opportunity to respond and contest the claims.
Immigration Operation Draws Protesters and Journalists
The confrontation occurred during a federal immigration enforcement operation on Rose Avenue.
According to the Minnesota Reformer's account, federal immigration agents attempted to arrest a man who fled into a residence.
A crowd gathered outside as the operation continued.
Journalists arrived to document the federal activity, the public response, and the conduct of law enforcement officers.
The three plaintiffs say they were carrying professional cameras and wearing visible press identification.
Evans was also wearing protective equipment identifying him as a member of the press.
The complaint alleges that the journalists were positioned apart from the main group of protesters when St. Paul police officers deployed crowd-control weapons.
According to the lawsuit, the officers' actions affected both demonstrators and journalists as police were leaving the area.
The distinction between demonstrators and journalists is central to the case.
Members of the press have the right to document events in public places, subject to lawful and constitutionally permissible restrictions. Their presence at a protest does not automatically make them participants in that protest.
At the same time, press identification does not exempt journalists from all lawful police orders or guarantee immunity from incidental exposure to crowd-control measures.
The legal dispute will depend on what officers did, what circumstances they faced, and whether their actions were justified under the law.
Journalists Describe Injuries
The complaint alleges that Yücel was sprayed with a chemical irritant at close range while photographing the scene.
He also alleges that officers struck him with pepper balls in the upper body.
According to the lawsuit, he experienced significant breathing difficulties and required ambulance transportation.
The complaint states that all three journalists experienced irritation affecting their eyes and respiratory systems.
Evans reportedly suffered bruising that persisted for approximately a month.
The plaintiffs also describe psychological effects following the confrontation and say they sought mental health treatment.
These accounts are allegations contained in the lawsuit and reported by the Minnesota Reformer. Their accuracy, the extent of any injuries, and the legal responsibility of individual officers remain matters for the proceedings.
Constitutional Claims and Police Accountability
The lawsuit alleges violations of the First, Fourth, and Fourteenth Amendments to the United States Constitution.
The First Amendment protects freedom of speech and the press.
The Fourth Amendment protects against unreasonable searches and seizures, including certain uses of force by government officers.
The Fourteenth Amendment provides constitutional protections that can be relevant to claims involving state and local government conduct.
The plaintiffs also assert claims involving assault and battery.
Police use-of-force cases are highly dependent on specific circumstances, including the conduct of officers and civilians, the nature of any threat, and whether the force used was objectively reasonable.
The plaintiffs contend that they were engaged in lawful newsgathering and were not threatening officers.
Their complaint alleges that the journalists were standing apart from protesters and were identifiable as press members.
Those assertions, if supported by evidence, could become important in evaluating the reasonableness of the officers' actions.
Police Chief Named in Lawsuit
The complaint names St. Paul Police Chief Axel Henry and alleges failures involving officer training and supervision.
The plaintiffs argue that inadequate preparation and oversight contributed to the alleged violations.
Such claims require evidence establishing the applicable legal standards and the relationship between supervisory conduct, departmental practices, and the alleged injuries.
The filing of a lawsuit against a police chief does not establish that the chief personally ordered or approved the conduct being challenged.
The Minnesota Reformer reported that a St. Paul Police Department spokesperson declined to comment because the matter involves pending litigation.
That response should not be characterized as an admission of wrongdoing.
The department's Civilian Internal Affairs Review Commission is also investigating the incident, according to the reporting.
The outcome of that review may provide additional information about officer conduct, departmental procedures, and possible administrative findings.
Press Freedom During Public Demonstrations
The case has implications extending beyond the three plaintiffs.
Photojournalists frequently work in unpredictable environments where protests, police operations, and confrontations can develop rapidly.
Their work provides the public with visual documentation of government actions and events that might otherwise remain poorly understood.
When journalists face force while carrying out that work, questions arise about whether police practices adequately distinguish between lawful newsgathering and conduct that may justify intervention.
A finding that officers intentionally targeted identifiable journalists without lawful justification would raise serious constitutional concerns.
However, the court must evaluate the evidence rather than assume the plaintiffs' allegations have already been proved.
The case also highlights the importance of police training concerning interactions with journalists during crowd-control operations.
Departments may need clear procedures addressing press identification, access to public areas, use-of-force decisions, and the treatment of journalists who are documenting police activity.
Plaintiffs Seek Damages and Court Intervention
The three journalists are seeking financial damages and attorney's fees.
They are also requesting injunctive relief intended to prevent future unconstitutional conduct against them.
An injunction would require a court to determine that the applicable legal standards for such relief have been met.
The lawsuit therefore seeks more than compensation for alleged injuries. It also asks the judiciary to address the possibility of future violations.
The litigation will provide an opportunity to examine evidence about the November 2025 operation, including officer actions, the journalists' locations, and the circumstances surrounding the deployment of chemical weapons.
For St. Paul, the case presents another test of public confidence in law enforcement accountability.
For Minnesota's news organizations, it raises concerns about the ability of reporters and photographers to document public events without facing unjustified interference.
The ultimate findings will depend on the evidence and the court's application of constitutional and state law.
Until then, the allegations remain disputed claims, and no determination of liability should be inferred from the filing.

STAY CONNECTED TO MINNEAPOLIMEDIA
Local stories matter. Subscribe free to MinneapoliMedia and receive independent news, community reporting and important updates from Minneapolis, the North Metro and communities across Minnesota.
SUBSCRIBE FREE: https://minneapolimedia.town.news/subscribe
MinneapoliMedia | Community. Culture. Civic Life