Image
Brenda is a wonderful woman, but she has always had an opinion about everything. If I complain that the grocery store was packed, she asks how many people were there. If I say somebody kept me waiting forever, she wants to know whether I mean forever or eleven minutes. If I tell her a woman at the pharmacy was rude, she asks what the woman said, whether I might have misunderstood her, and if I have considered the possibility that the woman was simply having a difficult day.
I once told Brenda that a neighbor had been giving me dirty looks. She asked whether I had spoken to the neighbor. I said no. She asked whether the neighbor had spoken to me. Again, no. Then she wanted to know what made me think the looks were dirty.
"Brenda, I know a dirty look when I receive one."
"Maybe she was squinting."
"At me?"
"She might have forgotten her glasses."
I told Brenda that I had not called her to provide legal representation for a woman who had been glaring at me across the street. I had called because I wanted a little sympathy. Brenda said sympathy was perfectly reasonable, but she preferred to establish what had happened before declaring somebody guilty.
This was the woman I wanted to change. Not completely, of course. I enjoyed her company, trusted her judgment, and appreciated having someone who would tell me when I was making a mistake. I simply wanted her to stop doing it quite so often, particularly when I was enjoying a good complaint.
Then, last Monday, Brenda changed.
We were having breakfast in my kitchen when I mentioned that the new bakery on Oak Street was charging six dollars for a cinnamon roll. Six dollars seemed excessive for something made primarily from flour, sugar, and the confidence of the person setting the price.
Ordinarily, Brenda would have reminded me that bakeries have employees, rent, insurance, and electricity bills. She might also have pointed out that I had recently paid eight dollars for a slice of cheesecake without expressing concern for the financial stability of the nation.
Instead, she nodded.
"You're right, Jane. Six dollars is quite a lot."
I waited for the rest.
Nothing came.
"Especially when the cinnamon roll isn't even particularly large," I added.
"Absolutely."
I put down my coffee.
"That's it?"
"What's it?"
"You're not going to explain why the bakery needs to charge six dollars?"
"No. If you think it's too expensive, you don't have to buy it."
I was astonished. For the first time in years, Brenda had allowed one of my opinions to remain undisturbed. I felt the satisfaction of a woman who had finally persuaded a stubborn relative to stop giving unsolicited advice.
I congratulated her on becoming more reasonable.
She thanked me.
I should have known something was wrong.
On Wednesday, Brenda explained that she had attended a personal-development workshop at the community center. The instructor had discussed listening, patience, and the importance of allowing people to express themselves without immediately correcting them. Participants had been encouraged to recognize the difference between someone seeking advice and someone simply wanting to be heard.
I considered this excellent instruction. In fact, I was surprised that Brenda had needed a workshop to discover something I had been telling her for fifteen years.
"Sometimes people just want sympathy," she explained.
"Exactly! That's what I've always said."
"I know."
"And you have a habit of challenging everything."
"I do."
"Even when nobody has asked for your opinion."
"That's true."
I leaned back in my chair and enjoyed the moment. For years, I had collected examples of Brenda's argumentative tendencies. Now she was admitting everything without requiring me to produce a single witness.
I asked whether the workshop had been expensive.
"Twenty-five dollars."
"Twenty-five dollars to learn not to argue?"
"Yes."
"Brenda, I could have taught you that for free."
She smiled.
"You're probably right."
I looked at her suspiciously. The old Brenda would have pointed out that I was currently arguing about the cost of a workshop designed to discourage unnecessary arguments. The new Brenda simply finished her coffee.
I decided that twenty-five dollars was a bargain.
By Thursday, however, I was beginning to question the investment.
We went to lunch at a restaurant Brenda had previously disliked because the service was slow and the soup arrived lukewarm. I remembered the place more favorably. It had attractive curtains, comfortable chairs, and a waitress who once brought me an extra biscuit without charging for it.
When I suggested returning, Brenda agreed immediately.
At the restaurant, the service was still slow. The soup was still lukewarm. The attractive curtains had been replaced by blinds, and the comfortable chairs were gone. I complained that the establishment had declined considerably.
"That's unfortunate," Brenda said.
"Don't you think the management should do something?"
"Probably."
"And the soup isn't hot enough."
"Would you like to ask them to warm it?"
I stared at her.
"Brenda, you used to have opinions about these things."
"I still do."
"Then why aren't you expressing them?"
"Because you seem to have the situation under control."
I looked at my soup. I did not have the situation under control. I had a bowl of warmish liquid and a friend who was behaving like the receptionist at a very expensive wellness retreat.
When the waitress returned, Brenda politely asked whether the soup could be heated. The waitress apologized and took it away. Brenda thanked her.
There was no complaint about the kitchen, no discussion of restaurant standards, and no observation about what customers should reasonably expect for fourteen dollars.
I was beginning to miss the old Brenda.
Over the next several days, Brenda's new personality became increasingly difficult to live with.
When I complained about the timing of a traffic light, she said she understood my frustration. When I mentioned that a cashier had been unpleasant, she said that sounded disappointing. When I announced that the weather forecast had been completely wrong, she suggested that forecasts were sometimes inaccurate.
She no longer asked for evidence. She did not question my recollection of events. She simply acknowledged my feelings and allowed me to continue.
At first, I enjoyed this arrangement. Then I discovered that conversations became surprisingly short when nobody challenged anything.
I told Brenda that I had waited nearly half an hour at the bank. She expressed sympathy and asked whether I had completed my business. I said yes, and she said she was glad.
That was the entire conversation.
I had been prepared to discuss customer service, staffing shortages, uncomfortable waiting-room chairs, and whether banks should provide refreshments to people who had been standing in line long enough to reconsider their financial arrangements. Instead, Brenda accepted my account and moved on to another subject.
I felt cheated.
I had never realized how much of our friendship depended on her disagreeing with me. Without Brenda's objections, I had no opportunity to explain why I was right. My complaints simply ended, leaving me with the uncomfortable responsibility of finding something else to talk about.
One afternoon, I decided to test her.
I told Brenda that I was considering buying another slow cooker.
"That sounds nice," she said.
"But I already have one."
"Yes, you do."
"And I hardly ever use it."
"That's true."
"Don't you think buying another one would be wasteful?"
She considered the question.
"If you don't need it, perhaps."
I waited for her to remind me that my existing slow cooker had spent most of the previous year occupying valuable cupboard space. Instead, she asked whether I had seen any interesting recipes.
I told her that she was becoming impossible to talk to.
She laughed.
"Jane, you've spent years asking me to stop correcting you. Now you're upset because I'm not correcting you."
"There's a difference between being less argumentative and having no opinions."
"I have opinions. I'm simply choosing when to share them."
This was deeply troubling. Brenda apparently possessed an entire collection of opinions that she was now keeping to herself. I had spent fifteen years complaining about those opinions, and now I wanted to know where she had put them.
By Friday, I had become sufficiently concerned to call Carol.
I explained that Brenda had undergone a dramatic personality change and that I was worried about her emotional well-being.
"What's happened?" Carol asked.
"She's become agreeable."
Carol was silent for a moment.
"Is that all?"
"Carol, you don't understand. She agrees with practically everything."
"That sounds pleasant."
"It was pleasant for about two days. Now it's exhausting."
Carol asked whether Brenda seemed unhappy. I admitted that she appeared more relaxed than I had seen her in years.
"Then why are you worried?"
"Because she isn't herself."
"Maybe she's becoming a better version of herself."
I disliked that suggestion immediately. I had no objection to Brenda improving herself. I simply believed improvement should preserve the recognizable features of the original person. When you replace a refrigerator, you expect it to operate more efficiently. You do not expect it to announce that it has decided to become a washing machine.
Carol suggested that I might be having difficulty adjusting.
I informed her that I was exceptionally adaptable. I had survived changes in television programming, restaurant menus, telephone technology, and the disappearance of sensible pockets from women's clothing. I could certainly adjust to a friend becoming more patient.
"Then why are you calling me?" Carol asked.
I explained that I wanted an independent assessment of Brenda's condition.
Carol laughed so hard that she had to put down her phone.
I decided she was not taking the matter seriously.
Margaret was more sympathetic, although she asked whether I had considered that Brenda might simply be tired of arguing.
"Brenda never gets tired of arguing," I said. "She once spent twenty minutes explaining why I was using the wrong container for leftover spaghetti."
"Was she right?"
"The container leaked, Margaret. But that's not the point."
Margaret advised me to support Brenda's efforts to become more patient. I agreed that this was the proper thing to do.
Then I invited Brenda to lunch on Saturday.
I had developed a plan.
I am not proud of what happened next, although my intentions were honorable. I wanted to establish whether Brenda's old personality was still present beneath all this newly acquired patience. I did not intend to provoke an argument. I merely wanted to create circumstances in which a reasonable woman would find it impossible not to object.
I began with the kitchen.
When Brenda arrived, I announced that I was considering storing my dinner plates in the cupboard above the refrigerator. This would free up space near the sink and allow me to organize my kitchen more efficiently.
Brenda looked at the cupboard.
"Wouldn't they be difficult to reach?"
My heart lifted.
"Not necessarily."
"You'd need a step stool every time you wanted a plate."
"I could manage."
She considered the arrangement.
"Well, if it works for you, it's your kitchen."
I nearly dropped my coffee.
For years, Brenda had expressed opinions about my dish towels, pantry shelves, and the way I stacked plastic containers. Now she was prepared to let me store heavy dinner plates in a location that required climbing equipment.
I moved to the dining room and announced that I might replace my dining table with a large coffee table because it would make the room feel more spacious.
"That could be interesting," Brenda said.
"But we'd have to eat sitting on the floor."
"Would you enjoy that?"
"Not particularly."
"Then perhaps keep the table."
She said this pleasantly, without the slightest indication that she considered my proposal ridiculous.
I was forced to escalate.
I told her that I had decided calendars were unnecessarily restrictive and that I intended to stop using them.
Brenda smiled.
"You might miss a few appointments."
I informed her that appointments were simply agreements between people who had become too dependent on clocks.
"That's one way of looking at it," she said.
I was losing hope.
Then I remembered parking.
Brenda has always been particular about parking. She believes drivers should stay between the painted lines, use their turn signals, and avoid occupying two spaces unless their vehicles are approximately the size of a school bus. I once watched her leave a note on a car that had been parked diagonally across two spaces. The note was polite, but it contained enough detail to qualify as a preliminary traffic report.
I told her that I had recently started parking diagonally whenever the lot was mostly empty.
She put down her fork.
"Diagonally?"
"Yes."
"Across the lines?"
"Sometimes."
"Jane, that's inconsiderate."
I felt a rush of affection.
"Why? If there are plenty of spaces, who cares?"
"Because other people still have to park."
"Perhaps the lines are too restrictive."
She stared at me.
"Are you seriously suggesting everyone should park wherever they feel like?"
"Why not? Freedom is important."
"Jane, freedom doesn't mean turning a parking lot into a guessing game."
There she was. The familiar tone, the narrowed eyes, the sudden appearance of a principle that could not be compromised.
I was so delighted that I laughed.
Brenda stopped.
"What's funny?"
"Nothing."
She studied me for several seconds.
"You've been doing this deliberately."
I denied it.
She reminded me that I had spent the afternoon proposing increasingly absurd household arrangements while waiting for her to object.
"Jane, you just told me you wanted to store your dinner plates above the refrigerator."
"It's an option."
"You can't reach the top shelf without standing on a chair."
"I could buy a step stool."
"And you don't park diagonally. You once made me move my car because one tire was touching a line."
I had forgotten that incident.
Brenda folded her arms.
"You've been trying to make me argue."
I looked at my plate.
"Perhaps a little."
She began laughing.
I found this response disappointing. I had been hoping for a proper disagreement, not amusement.
When Brenda stopped laughing, she asked why I had spent the afternoon trying to provoke her.
I considered explaining that I was conducting an informal assessment of her psychological adjustment, but she knew me too well for that explanation to survive.
"I miss you," I said.
She looked surprised.
"I'm right here."
"I know. But you're different."
"Jane, I've been trying to become less critical. You've told me for years that I correct you too much."
"I know."
"And now you're upset because I'm not correcting you?"
"When you put it that way, it sounds unreasonable."
"How else would you put it?"
I thought about that for a moment.
"I suppose I miss our arguments."
Brenda smiled.
"We haven't stopped talking."
"No, but it's different. I say something, and you agree. Then I say something else, and you agree again. It's like having a conversation with a very polite answering machine."
She laughed.
I explained that I had never realized how much I enjoyed defending my opinions against hers. Brenda's objections irritated me, but they also made our conversations interesting. She noticed details I overlooked, challenged assumptions I had become comfortable with, and occasionally forced me to admit that I was wrong.
Not frequently, of course. But occasionally.
"I thought you hated that," she said.
"I thought I did too."
Brenda admitted that she might have taken the workshop's advice too far. She had become so determined not to interrupt or correct people that she sometimes withheld opinions she genuinely wanted to express.
"I used to think every inaccurate statement needed correcting," she said. "Sometimes you just want to complain about a bad day. You don't need me to investigate whether it was technically as bad as you say."
"That's true."
"But that doesn't mean I should stop being honest with you."
"Exactly."
"And it doesn't mean you should invent ridiculous opinions just to make me disagree."
I considered this.
"Well, perhaps not all the time."
She laughed again.
For the first time that week, I felt as though I was speaking to my old friend. Not because she had abandoned everything she learned, but because she had stopped treating patience as an obligation to remain silent.
We agreed that she would continue trying to listen more carefully, and I would stop treating every correction as a personal attack. If I wanted sympathy, I could say so. If I wanted her opinion, I could ask for it.
I thought this was an excellent arrangement, although I pointed out that I should not have to announce what kind of conversation we were having every time I opened my mouth.
Brenda looked at me.
I looked back.
"All right," I said. "I'll try."
After Brenda left, I spent some time thinking about the peculiar demands we place on people we love.
We complain about their habits and urge them to change. We tell them to become more patient, more punctual, less critical, or more independent. We imagine that if they would simply correct these irritating qualities, our relationships would become easier.
Then they change, and we discover that we have grown accustomed to the very things we wanted removed.
Margaret had once complained that her husband reminded her constantly about locking the back door. When he finally stopped, she found herself checking it three times every evening because she no longer trusted that he had checked it. Carol had spent years wishing her daughter would become more independent, then felt strangely unnecessary when the young woman began making important decisions without consulting her.
These were not tragedies. They were ordinary adjustments to the uncomfortable fact that other people do not exist solely to satisfy our expectations.
I had wanted Brenda to become more patient, but I had imagined that patience would make her easier for me to deal with. I had not considered that it might also change the rhythm of our friendship. Her objections had become so familiar that I sometimes depended on them to keep a conversation going.
The irony was difficult to ignore. I had complained about Brenda's habit of questioning everything, then spent an entire afternoon trying to force her to question me.
I was not opposed to personal growth. I simply wanted the right to approve the final product.
That, I reluctantly admitted, was not a reasonable position.
Brenda was entitled to change. She was also entitled to retain the parts of herself that mattered to her. My responsibility as her friend was not to supervise her development but to make room for it, even when the result required me to adjust.
I felt rather pleased with this realization.
Then Brenda called on Sunday morning.
She wanted to tell me that she had enjoyed our conversation and appreciated my honesty.
I told her I felt the same way.
Then I mentioned that I was reorganizing my pantry and considering putting the canned goods on the highest shelf.
There was a pause.
"Jane, those cans are heavy."
"I know."
"And you shouldn't be lifting them over your head."
"I'll be careful."
"That's what you said before you dropped the jar of pickles."
I sighed.
"Brenda, that happened three years ago."
"Two years and eight months."
I smiled despite myself.
There she was again.
We spent several minutes discussing the pantry, and I agreed that the canned goods should probably remain on a lower shelf. Brenda then questioned my plan to purchase a second slow cooker, pointing out that the first one had spent most of the previous year gathering dust.
I explained that owning two slow cookers would give me greater flexibility.
"What would you cook in the second one?" she asked.
I had no immediate answer.
She laughed.
I laughed too.
It was wonderful.
Before hanging up, I told Brenda that I supported her personal growth completely. I wanted her to become whatever kind of person she wished to be, and I promised not to make her feel guilty for changing.
She thanked me warmly.
I considered the conversation a significant achievement. We had discussed a disagreement without becoming defensive, reached a practical compromise, and demonstrated that friendship could accommodate change without losing its essential character.
I was feeling rather mature when Brenda sent me a message twenty minutes later.
"By the way, I've decided to stop drinking coffee."
I stared at the screen.
Brenda and I had been meeting for coffee for fifteen years. We had discussed marriages, children, neighbors, books, disappointing vacations, and the mysterious disappearance of matching socks over countless cups of coffee. Our regular meetings were one of the foundations of our friendship.
I called her immediately.
"Brenda, what do you mean you're giving up coffee?"
"Exactly that. I've been thinking about it for a while."
"But why?"
"I want to sleep better."
"Have you considered drinking less?"
"I have."
"Or switching to decaf?"
"I don't particularly enjoy decaf."
"Well, perhaps you could still have coffee when we meet."
She laughed.
"Jane, I thought you supported my personal growth."
"Of course I do."
"Then what's the problem?"
I looked at my coffee cup.
"Brenda, we've been having coffee together for fifteen years."
"We can still meet, Jane. I'll have tea."
Tea.
She said it as though this were a perfectly acceptable substitute for a friendship built on caffeine, conversation, and the occasional argument about the price of pastries.
I tried to remain calm.
"Well, if that's what you want, I suppose I'll have to respect your decision."
"Thank you."
We said goodbye.
I sat in my kitchen for several minutes, considering the situation. I had spent the entire weekend learning to accept that people change. I had apologized for trying to preserve Brenda's old habits and had assured her that I supported whatever kind of person she wished to become.
Now she was giving up coffee.
I decided that I needed to demonstrate maturity.
I opened my calendar and found our next scheduled meeting.
Tuesday, 2:00 p.m. Coffee with Brenda.
I changed it to:
Tuesday, 2:00 p.m. Tea with Brenda.
I examined the entry.
It looked wrong. It sounded less like an afternoon with my closest friend and more like an appointment to discuss digestive health.
I changed it back.
Tuesday, 2:00 p.m. Coffee with Brenda.
Then I added a note.
Brenda may drink tea. Do not make an issue of it.
I considered this a reasonable compromise. It respected Brenda's decision while preserving the essential character of our friendship.
A few minutes later, another message arrived.
"I've also been thinking about trying that new place that serves herbal infusions instead of coffee. Would you like to go there Tuesday?"
Herbal infusions.
I read the message twice.
I had spent years wishing Brenda would change, and now she was apparently determined to become an entirely different species.
I began typing a reply.
"Brenda, I support your growth, but there are limits."
I looked at the message, remembered our conversation, and deleted it.
Instead, I wrote, "Of course. That sounds lovely."
She replied with a smiling face.
I congratulated myself on my remarkable emotional progress.
Then I opened my calendar again.
Tuesday, 2:00 p.m. Herbal infusions with Brenda.
I studied the entry for several seconds before adding one final reminder.
Bring emergency coffee.
I considered that perfectly reasonable.
I was prepared to accept the new Brenda. I was even willing to sit in a café that served beverages made from boiled leaves and described them as an experience.
But I had one condition.
If Brenda was going to become the sort of woman who drank herbal infusions, she was going to have to accept that I was still the sort of woman who brought her own coffee.
After all, personal growth works both ways.
And if she complained about the smell, I intended to remind her that she had paid twenty-five dollars to learn how to stop correcting people.

Local stories matter. Subscribe free to MinneapoliMedia and receive independent news, community reporting and important updates from Minneapolis, the North Metro and communities across Minnesota.
SUBSCRIBE FREE: https://minneapolimedia.town.news/subscribe
MinneapoliMedia | Community. Culture. Civic Life