Jury Finds Sen. Nicole Mitchell Guilty On Both Counts In Burglary Trial
Detroit Lakes, MN (July 18, 2025) – A Becker County jury has convicted Minnesota State Senator Nicole Mitchell (DFL‑Woodbury) on both felony charges of first‑degree burglary and possession of burglary tools. The verdict culminates a high‑profile trial stemming from an April 22, 2024 incident at her stepmother’s home.
Trial Overview
Incident: On April 22, 2024, Detroit Lakes police responded to a burglary call at Carol Mitchell’s home. They found Sen. Mitchell—dressed in black and carrying tools including a flashlight covered by a sock, latex gloves, and a small crowbar—inside the basement. Mitchell initially told officers she had entered to retrieve her late father’s ashes and personal items.
Jury Deliberation: After three days of testimony and closing arguments, a jury of nine men and three women began deliberations around 12:30 p.m. on July 18 and returned a guilty verdict just after 4 p.m., following approximately three hours.
Key Testimony & Evidence
Prosecution: Highlighted body‑camera footage and Mitchell’s own admission—“I know I did something bad”—arguing her intent was to steal. Becker County Attorney Brian McDonald emphasized, “Who packs a prybar just in case?”.
Defense: Mitchell testified for nearly five hours, stating her motive was a welfare check on her stepmother, who suffers from Alzheimer’s. Her team portrayed her initial statements as “white lies” intended to prevent alarming Carol. Defense attorney Dane DeKrey praised her courage under intense cross‑examination.
Political & Legal Fallout
Senate Balance: Democrats hold a razor‑thin one‑seat majority. Mitchell had continued to cast decisive votes during the trial, prompting immediate criticism.
Resignation Pledge: Senate Majority Leader Erin Murphy stated Mitchell had promised to resign if convicted and “I expect her to follow through”. Senate Minority Leader Mark Johnson decried the verdict as a stain on the institution and urged immediate removal.
Governor & Party Reaction: Gov. Tim Walz and DFL leaders echoed calls for resignation or expulsion via special session. If Mitchell steps down, a special election in her Democratic‑leaning district could change control of the Senate.
Next Steps & Sentencing
No Custody Yet: Judge Fritz denied immediate detention; Mitchell remains free pending sentencing. A date has not been set.
Potential Penalties: First‑degree burglary carries a mandatory minimum of six months in jail and up to 20 years. Possession of burglary tools adds up to three years and a $5,000 fine.
Appeal Likely: Her defense team plans to explore options for appeal.
60° and Sunny
