Minnesota mom charged with stealing $110,000 from daughter’s softball association

A 52 year old Maple Grove woman who served as a volunteer treasurer for a Twin Cities youth softball league is accused of stealing more than $110,000 from the organization over nearly five years, according to a criminal complaint filed in Hennepin County District Court.

Kristin Allyenne Williams was charged by summons on December 31, 2025, with one count of felony theft by swindle for allegedly taking funds from the Plymouth Wayzata Youth Softball Association, a parent run nonprofit that serves families in the west metro.

Williams is the mother of two daughters who played in the league. She served as the association’s treasurer from June 2020 until she was removed from the position in February 2025.

Allegations outlined in the complaint

According to prosecutors, Williams had sole control over the association’s finances. As treasurer, she was responsible for all accounting, bookkeeping, and web based transactions and was the only person with access to the group’s U.S. Bank account and debit card.

The complaint alleges that between August 2020 and February 2025, Williams siphoned off more than $110,000 for personal use.

Investigators say the scheme included numerous unauthorized ATM withdrawals at local casinos, including Mystic Lake Casino and Little Six Casino. The league president, Tim Lyons, told investigators there was no legitimate reason for the treasurer to withdraw cash, as tournament and operational cash needs were handled separately by the association’s leadership.

How the alleged theft was concealed

Charging documents allege Williams falsified financial reports presented to the board in order to hide missing funds. Prosecutors say she concealed the theft by underreporting deposits or misclassifying stolen money under expense categories such as clinic expenses or equipment costs.

While Williams initially appeared to perform her duties competently, the complaint says warning signs emerged as she stopped attending board meetings and failed to pay vendors and coaches, disrupting league operations.

Red flags and discovery

The alleged theft was not uncovered until September 2024, when the association received notice from the Internal Revenue Service that it had lost its tax exempt status after failing to file required federal returns for three consecutive years.

Williams was removed as treasurer in early 2025. A subsequent review and audit of bank records by board members revealed the extent of the alleged financial losses.

The Plymouth Wayzata Youth Softball Association was founded in 1989 and is run entirely by unpaid parent volunteers. At the time of Williams’ appointment, the association publicly praised her in a social media post, citing more than 15 years of experience in finance.

Legal status and next steps

Williams faces one felony count of theft by swindle. She was charged by summons and is scheduled to make her first court appearance on January 21, 2026.

In a statement to families, the association’s board said it is cooperating fully with law enforcement and is focused on restoring financial stability while the legal process moves forward.

Felony theft by swindle carries significant potential penalties under Minnesota law. Prosecutors say the case relies heavily on bank records, internal financial statements, and Williams’ exclusive authority over the organization’s accounts.

For families involved in youth sports, the case underscores how deeply financial misconduct can affect volunteer run programs that rely on trust, transparency, and limited resources to operate.

MinneapoliMedia