SUNDAY WITH PHILOSOPHY JANE | Nobody Ever Leaves When They Say They’re Leaving

By Sunday afternoon, I had watched three separate adults announce they were leaving and then stay long enough to eat a second meal.

The first announcement came right after dessert. A man slapped both hands on his knees, leaned forward, and said, "Well."

Every adult in the room understood. The kids did not. Children haven't learned that "Well" isn't just a word. It's a public notice. It means an adult has decided to start the long process of going home.

Nobody moved. The man stayed sitting. His wife stayed sitting. The host stayed sitting. The dog looked up from the rug, realized nobody was actually opening a door, and went back to sleep.

In a lot of homes, saying you are leaving carries about the same weight as saying you are going to clean out the garage this weekend. You might mean it, but nobody is holding their breath.

A few minutes later, he tried again. "I suppose we should get moving."

People nodded. Someone looked at the wall clock. Someone else mentioned it was getting late, even though the sun was still up and nobody had anywhere to be.

Then the host said, "Before you go, did I tell you what happened to Linda at the pharmacy?"

That was it. The departure was officially over. Nothing stops a goodbye like a story about someone named Linda at a store. The man settled back into his chair, his wife put her purse on the floor, and the dog closed his eyes again.

The Power of "Before You Go"

"Before you go" is a trap. It sounds small and quick. It promises one quick thought before everyone heads out, but it never works that way.

"Before you go" usually leads into a medical update, a property line argument, a family scandal, a casserole recipe, or a twenty-minute explanation of why someone stopped shopping at a specific hardware store. Nobody says, "Before you go, the porch light is on," and then lets you leave. There is always a backstory, and there is almost always a cousin involved.

The story about Linda at the pharmacy needed context dating back to Easter three years ago. By the time it wrapped up, two people had forgotten why anyone stood up in the first place.

This happens everywhere people are having a good time and don't want to admit the visit is over. At Sunday dinners, leaving starts at dessert and ends when the weather changes. At church, the service ends in the building, but the real meeting happens in the parking lot. At cookouts, people say they should head out, then stand by the cold grill talking about property taxes until someone brings out another tray of bars.

Nobody just leaves. It happens in stages:

1. The Seated Goodbye
2. The Standing Goodbye
3. The Hallway Goodbye
4. The Doorknob Goodbye
5. The Porch Goodbye
6. The Driveway Goodbye
7. The Car-Door Goodbye
8. The Rolled-Down-Window Goodbye
9. The Text Message Five Minutes Later ("Forgot to tell you something")

By the time you get the text, the visit has a sequel.

The Doorknob Portal

I watched this play out at a family gathering where everyone claimed they had to leave by six sharp.

At 5:47, someone checked their watch. At 5:51, someone said we should get moving. At 5:55, purses appeared. At 6:02, a child was told to find his shoes. At 6:11, the child came back with one boot and a dog toy. At 6:24, someone remembered the leftovers. At 6:39, the containers were packed, unpacked, and wiped down because the potato salad was leaking.

At 6:45, everyone finally reached the front door.

That's when the real conversation started. Front doors do something strange to people. You can sit in a living room for three hours talking about nothing urgent. The second someone touches the doorknob, brand new information suddenly appears.

"Did you hear about the Johnsons?" "Who did your roof?" "Are you still taking that medicine?" "Have you noticed the tree next door leaning toward the garage?"

None of these questions came up at the table where everyone was comfortable. They came up at the door while four people were sweating in winter coats and a kid was standing on the rug in his socks. The brain seems to panic when it realizes you are about to leave, so it dumps whatever is left in your head all at once.

We stood in that entryway for another eighteen minutes. Someone cracked the door open, cold air came in, and someone else said it was getting chilly. That led to the forecast, which led to road salt, which led to winter tires, which led to a mechanic in town who is honest but never answers his phone.

Nobody left. The kid sat on the floor and took off the one boot he had spent twenty minutes finding. Smart kid.

Leaving vs. Leaving Leaving

Children understand adult goodbyes better than adults do.

When parents say it's time to go, little kids fight it because they want to keep playing. Older kids don't fight it because they know the first announcement doesn't mean anything.

I know a seven-year-old who doesn't even look up when his parents say it's time to go. His mom says, "Get your coat," and he keeps building with his Legos. His dad says, "We are leaving right now," and he adds another floor to his tower. Someone opens the front door, and he puts a roof on the building. Only when an adult uses his middle name does he start looking for his shoes.

He knows the difference between leaving and leaving, leaving.

Leaving is when adults talk about going home. Leaving, leaving is when the car is actively rolling down the street.

Even the car isn't a guarantee. I've seen parents buckle kids into the back seat, start the engine, roll down the window, and keep talking across the driveway for half an hour. The kids sit in the back with their snacks and blankets, completely stuck. One boy finally rolled down his window and shouted, "Are we going home or do we live here now?" Nobody answered him because the adults were talking about lawn fertilizer.

The Driveway Residency

The driveway is where goodbyes get completely out of hand. Nobody plans a driveway visit. Nobody sends a text saying, "Come over Sunday, we'll stand next to my car in forty-degree weather for an hour." But that's where the longest talks happen.

The car is unlocked, the trunk is shut, and the engine might even be running. One person stands by the driver's window with a hand on the roof. Another stands near the bumper. Someone else is holding a plastic bowl of leftover chicken that hasn't made it into the car yet.

Driveway talks cover everything: school board meetings, knee replacements, garbage raccoons, and the one right way to freeze sweet corn.

I once watched a family spend twenty-five minutes saying goodbye next to an idling SUV. The driver had his foot on the brake and both hands on the wheel. Every part of him looked ready to drive away except his mouth. A relative leaned into the window and said, "One more thing."

It's never one thing. "One more thing" is a list disguised as a sentence. By the time the relative finished, the driver turned off the engine to save gas. They had settled in for the long haul.

Then someone remembered the pie.

Food always waits until the last second to become an emergency. You can sit in a house for hours without seeing a single baked good. The second your foot hits the driveway, someone yells, "You forgot the pie!"

You say, "That's fine, don't worry about it." The host acts like you just turned down a life raft. "No, you're taking it," they say, and run back inside.

You stand by the trunk, other relatives wander over, a new conversation starts, and the host comes back with the pie, a bag of rolls, two apples, and a container of turkey nobody asked for. That's how you leave a family dinner with enough food to survive a blizzard.

Grandmothers are famous for this. A grandmother doesn't let you leave; she supplies an expedition. It doesn't matter if you're driving across three states or five minutes down the road.

"Do you have water?" "Yes, I'm fine." "Take another bottle."

Then come the paper towels, the extra flashlight, and warnings about deer on the road. You can't say no. A grandmother offering food isn't asking a question; she's giving an order because she cares about you.

Why We Linger

Everything else in life is built for speed: fast checkout, instant shipping, quick text messages. We praise anything that saves a minute, then spend those saved minutes staring at our phones.

Goodbyes don't work that way. They are slow on purpose. No app has fixed them, and texting has just made them longer. Now, ten minutes after you finally drive away, your phone buzzes: "Made it home safe. Forgot to tell you about Thursday."

The goodbye didn't end. It just moved to your phone.

I did this exact same thing last week after spending an afternoon with friends. Nothing special happened. We just ate, talked, and laughed about a neighbor who bought a leaf blower that sounds like an airplane taking off.

Eventually, I checked the time, slapped my knees, and said, "Well." Everyone laughed because they knew what it meant.

I stood up, immediately remembered a story, and told it while standing in the living room. Someone asked a question, and I answered it while putting on my coat. We talked about a new restaurant while standing by the front door. Outside, we talked about a weird light on my dashboard. Beside the car, I remembered I owed someone a phone number. I rolled down the window to say one last thing, and finally got home forty minutes after I said I was leaving.

Then I pulled out my phone and texted: "Forgot to say, the soup was great."

I looked at the phone and had to laugh. I spent almost an hour leaving and still didn't finish what I wanted to say.

That's when I stopped worrying about long goodbyes. We aren't bad at leaving. We're just good at realizing, for a few extra minutes, that we had a good time and don't want it to end.

Most of life doesn't give you a warning before a normal moment turns into a memory. Nobody rings a bell during the last casual dinner before a friend moves away. Nobody tells you this is the last holiday where everyone sits at the same table. You usually only realize how good a moment was after it's over.

So we stand by the door because one more story might come up. We stay in the driveway because everyone is laughing again. We roll down the window because we aren't quite ready to go. The clock says the visit is over, but the people say not yet.

Last Sunday, I looked out my window and saw a car parked across the street. The driver's door was open, the engine was running, and someone was standing on the pavement holding a plate wrapped in foil. Two kids were sitting in the back seat, waiting quietly. Everyone was laughing.

The driver started to pull away, hit the brakes, and rolled down the window. Someone walked back over to the car. I couldn't hear what they said, but I knew. One more thing.

The conversation started back up. They weren't being fast or efficient. They were just enjoying being together a little bit longer.

Eventually, the car pulled away, people waved from the lawn, and the car turned the corner. A few seconds later, I heard a phone buzz on the counter across the street.

Nobody ever leaves when they say they are leaving, and honestly, that's probably a good thing.

MinneapoliMedia | Community. Culture. Civic Life.